Republicans Poised to Dismiss Democrats’ Plan to Resolve Longest Shutdown in U.S. History | Federal Government Shutdown 2025
Republicans Reject Democratic Proposal Amid Ongoing Government Shutdown
Republicans are poised to reject a proposal from Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer aimed at ending the longest government shutdown in U.S. history. This proposal includes a deal to reauthorize funding in exchange for a one-year extension of tax credits designed to lower costs for Affordable Care Act (ACA) health plans.
Democratic Push for Legislative Action
“Democrats are ready to clear the way to quickly pass a government funding bill that includes healthcare affordability,” Schumer stated on the Senate floor. He emphasized the necessity for Republican Leader John Thune to add a straightforward, one-year extension of the ACA tax credits to the continuing resolution (CR), urging immediate action to address rising healthcare costs.
Proposed Bipartisan Committee
Additionally, Schumer suggested the formation of a bipartisan committee to continue negotiations after the government reopens. The goal would be to implement reforms before the upcoming enrollment period, ensuring long-term stability in healthcare costs.
Response from Senate Republicans
However, Senate Majority Leader John Thune remains unyielding, with his spokesperson, Ryan Wrasse, reiterating the demand for the government to reopen before any discussion on tax credits can take place. “Extending the COVID bonuses is the negotiation—something that can only happen after the government reopens. Release the hostage. End the pain,” Wrasse asserted.
Impact of the Shutdown
Any potential compromise would also need the approval of the House of Representatives, currently in recess since September 19, suggesting that the 38-day shutdown will not conclude immediately. This disruption has led to significant challenges for Americans, ranging from halted government services to delayed food aid programs, with some 800 flights canceled due to the fallout from the shutdown.
Bipartisan Support Needed
Despite Republican control of both chambers, any spending legislation requires bipartisan support to surpass the 60-vote threshold in the Senate. Thune has made numerous attempts to gain Democratic support for a House-approved bill extending funding through November 21, but only three members from the minority party have backed it.
Democratic Stance on Funding Bill
Democrats have asserted that any funding bill must include an extension of tax credits initiated during Joe Biden’s administration, set to expire at the end of the year. Without these, individuals on ACA plans could face an average cost increase of 26%, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation.
Economic Concerns
Kevin Hassett, director of the National Economic Council, indicated that the shutdown could reduce GDP growth by nearly half in the current quarter, although much of this loss is anticipated to be regained if the shutdown resolves soon and federal workers receive back pay.
Recent Election Results Influence Political Strategy
Following the results of recent off-year elections where Democratic candidates achieved significant victories, party leaders believe public sentiment supports their demands. Schumer remarked, “Americans plagued by high costs fired a political torpedo this week at Donald Trump and Republicans,” urging the GOP to reassess their approach.
Shifting Public Opinion
Polls indicate that Republicans are increasingly held accountable for the shutdown, raising concerns among party members about the implications of conceding to Democratic demands. Senator Chris Murphy highlighted the risk of damaging a rehabilitated Democratic brand if they appear to surrender without negotiating effectively.
Trump’s Call for Change
Former President Trump has recognized the challenging dynamics for Republicans, cautioning that the shutdown may negatively impact their standing. He urged his party to consider eliminating the Senate filibuster, which currently allows a minority to block legislation unless it garners 60 votes. “If Republicans kill the Filibuster, they sail to victory for many years to come. If they don’t, it’s disaster waiting to happen!” he wrote on Truth Social.
